Recently, I was talking with fisharson and Phazys about upcoming shows, and Umineko No Naku Koro Ni, the English title of which translates to “When Seagulls Cry”. Both noted that the title certainly didn’t seem quite as sinister as it’s predecessor, Higurashi No Naku Koro Ni (lit. “When Cicadas Cry”). I pointed out that, being a coastal city dweller myself, the long and somewhat mournful call of a seagull was incredibly evocative and very closely associated with the location, and I felt it was plenty appropriate. Still, fisharson wasn’t quite impressed – the most recent seagulls that featured prominently in animated media after all are the button-eyed sort in Pixar’s Finding Nemo. While certainly menacing to the fish, their design is such to elicit amusement from the viewer – certainly, couldn’t a better choice have been made for a horror anime been made?
That then led me to another train of thought – well, we are discussing a Japanese work here, so perhaps something is lost in translation? Perhaps the Japanese have a set of refined sensibilities regarding seagulls that we New World gas-guzzling ingrates lack? Maybe they are in fact some majestic totem animal, their cries heralding the coming of salt spray and divine-sent typhoons. fisharson commented that the word for seagull in the title, “umineko”, could be broken down into “umi” – sea, and “neko” – cat. Sea Cats? Very well then, perhaps not exactly the most menacing metaphor, but perhaps we’re just missing some cultural nuance, in which case we should sigh and resign ourselves to never understanding this inscrutable culture.
Nevertheless, after some further consulation, fisharson found that “seagull” actually more properly translates into “kamome”. I suggested perhaps that “Umineko” might then refer to some specific subspecies of seagull – that guess proved to be right on the mark. “Umineko” refers not to the North American Common Gull of which we are familiar, but rather the Southeast Asian Black-tailed Gull.
It seems the answer to our question was much simpler than we originally thought. Quite simply, the Black-Tailed Gull is a scary looking bird. Look at the blood red slashes around the eyes and beak, almost as if the gull was stained with blood. It looks appropriate enough for a horror/murder mystery sort of title.
That whole anecdote is something of a tangent, but it did serve to show how even familiar terms and names can change depending on the context.
July 7, 2009 at 3:55 pm
Well, well, well. That black-tailed gull does look like a nasty piece of work.
I think I associate cicadas with heat so oppressive you can barely move, and I find them much more alien and unpleasant than even black-tailed gulls.
July 7, 2009 at 9:35 pm
Cicadas definitely have more going for them in terms of creepiness, due to the fact they’re insects; and they’re also literally quite alien in North America, being found only in the East Coast (and even then, those cicadas are the sort that come out to breed one night out of every decade or so and that’s it).
But I’m not really sure how alien they would be to a person who’s lived all their life in Southeast Asia – much as seagulls mean “the coast”, cicadas mean “the countryside”, or somesuch, perhaps.
There’s really a lot of subtle differences in various subspecies between Europe, Asia, and North America – it’s not just limited to seagulls, so I imagine this also may shape perceptions of what are considered “everyday” animals.
July 8, 2009 at 12:03 am
Ah thanks for that research. I was wondering too why it was named seagulls cry. I mean, cicadas, their cries are ominous and brooding. Seagulls? But that bird right there more than qualifies for horror anime title x_x
July 8, 2009 at 8:59 am
I’m fairly inured to cicadas from time spent in the Mediterranean — I think the reason I find them alien is because they’re insects.
But I don’t doubt you’re right that what you might call the ‘default animal soundscape’ must vary a lot from place to place.
March 21, 2010 at 8:01 am
yiw12216 -__________-
March 16, 2017 at 10:41 pm
Reblogged this on haveyouexperiencedshitsurakuen and commented:
Absolutely fascinating. Still need to read Umineko tho, lol.